योगवासिष्ठः
yogavāsiṣṭhaḥ
-
book-7, chapter-206, verse-17
निर्द्रव्यं कुरुते द्रव्यैर्युक्तिरित्यसमञ्जसा ।
मातापित्राद्यभावो हि बीजं किं तत्र कारणम् ॥ १७ ॥
मातापित्राद्यभावो हि बीजं किं तत्र कारणम् ॥ १७ ॥
nirdravyaṃ kurute dravyairyuktirityasamañjasā ,
mātāpitrādyabhāvo hi bījaṃ kiṃ tatra kāraṇam 17
mātāpitrādyabhāvo hi bījaṃ kiṃ tatra kāraṇam 17
17.
nirdravyam kurute dravyaiḥ yuktiḥ iti asamañjasā
mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ hi bījam kim tatra kāraṇam
mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ hi bījam kim tatra kāraṇam
17.
nirdravyam dravyaiḥ kurute iti yuktiḥ asamañjasā.
hi tatra mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ kim bījam kāraṇam
hi tatra mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ kim bījam kāraṇam
17.
This argument is inconsistent: that one creates a material body (dravyaiḥ) for a non-material entity (nirdravyam). Indeed, what is the seed or the cause for the manifestation (of a body) where there is an absence of a mother, a father, and so forth?
Words meanings summery:
(Scroll down for elaborated words morphology)
- निर्द्रव्यम् (nirdravyam) - without substance, immaterial, non-material
- कुरुते (kurute) - makes, does, creates
- द्रव्यैः (dravyaiḥ) - by means of substances, with materials
- युक्तिः (yuktiḥ) - reasoning, argument, logic, method
- इति (iti) - thus, in this way, so
- असमञ्जसा (asamañjasā) - inconsistent, improper, unsuitable, contradictory
- मातापित्राद्यभावः (mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ) - absence of mother, father, etc.
- हि (hi) - indeed, surely, because
- बीजम् (bījam) - seed, origin, primary cause
- किम् (kim) - what?
- तत्र (tatra) - there, in that matter
- कारणम् (kāraṇam) - the cause
Words meanings and morphology
निर्द्रव्यम् (nirdravyam) - without substance, immaterial, non-material
(adjective)
Accusative, neuter, singular of nirdravya
nirdravya - without substance, immaterial, substance-less
Bahuvrīhi compound (nis- + dravya)
Compound type : Bahuvrīhi (nis+dravya)
- nis – out, forth, without
prefix
Prefix indicating negation or absence - dravya – substance, material, thing, object
noun (neuter)
Note: Object of 'kurute'
कुरुते (kurute) - makes, does, creates
(verb)
3rd person , singular, middle, present (laṭ) of kṛ
Present 3rd person singular middle
Root: kṛ (class 8)
द्रव्यैः (dravyaiḥ) - by means of substances, with materials
(noun)
Instrumental, neuter, plural of dravya
dravya - substance, material, thing, object, wealth
Note: Means or instrument by which an action is performed
युक्तिः (yuktiḥ) - reasoning, argument, logic, method
(noun)
Nominative, feminine, singular of yukti
yukti - joining, union, connection, application, argument, reasoning, logic, method, skill
Derived from root yuj (to join)
Root: yuj (class 7)
Note: Subject of the implied verb 'asti' (is)
इति (iti) - thus, in this way, so
(indeclinable)
Note: Refers to the preceding statement as a 'reasoning'
असमञ्जसा (asamañjasā) - inconsistent, improper, unsuitable, contradictory
(adjective)
Nominative, feminine, singular of asamañjasa
asamañjasa - inconsistent, unsuitable, improper, contradictory, unseemly
Nañ-tatpuruṣa compound
Compound type : Nañ-tatpuruṣa (a+samañjasa)
- a – not, non-
prefix
Negative prefix - samañjasa – proper, suitable, consistent
adjective (masculine)
Compound of sam- (with) and añjasa (straight)
Prefix: sam
Root: añj (class 7)
Note: Agrees with 'yuktiḥ'
मातापित्राद्यभावः (mātāpitrādyabhāvaḥ) - absence of mother, father, etc.
(noun)
Nominative, masculine, singular of mātāpitrādyabhāva
mātāpitrādyabhāva - absence of mother, father, and so on
Tatpuruṣa compound of mātāpitṛ (parents), ādi (etc.), and abhāva (absence)
Compound type : Tatpuruṣa (mātāpitṛ+ādi+abhāva)
- mātāpitṛ – mother and father, parents
noun (masculine)
Dvandva compound - ādi – beginning, start, and so on, etc.
noun (masculine) - abhāva – absence, non-existence, annihilation
noun (masculine)
Nañ-tatpuruṣa compound of a- (not) and bhāva (existence)
Root: bhū (class 1)
Note: Subject of the question
हि (hi) - indeed, surely, because
(indeclinable)
बीजम् (bījam) - seed, origin, primary cause
(noun)
Nominative, neuter, singular of bīja
bīja - seed, germ, origin, primary cause, element
किम् (kim) - what?
(pronoun)
Nominative, neuter, singular of kim
kim - what, which, who; whether, why
Note: Interrogative pronoun
तत्र (tatra) - there, in that matter
(indeclinable)
Note: Refers to the context of absence of parents
कारणम् (kāraṇam) - the cause
(noun)
Nominative, neuter, singular of kāraṇa
kāraṇa - cause, reason, instrument
Derived from root kṛ (to do) with suffix -ana
Root: kṛ (class 8)